Real Estate IRA Tax Rates

Question: When you receive an IRA distribution of cash that was made from the sale of real estate, it is taxed at ordinary income tax rates. Isn’t this rate much higher than the capital gains rate you would pay on the sale of real estate outside of the IRA?

Yes, Traditional IRAs give you a tax deduction for contributions and you pay taxes on distributions. Both are at ordinary income rates which are higher than capital gains rates. This is true for any IRA asset, not just real estate.  Even if your IRA invested in securities like stocks and mutual funds instead of real estate, distributions of any gains will be taxed ordinary income tax rates.

If your goal is to minimize taxes at distribution you may wish to convert your existing Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA.  Distributions from Roth IRAs are generally tax-free.  Conversion may be done at any time; income tax at ordinary income will be due on the converted amount. Many investors feel the Roth IRA is a much better long term plan as the taxes are effectively prepaid on the money.  Both contributions and the income and profits are withdrawn tax free.

Recently, much of the appeal of real estate investing is the positive cash flow it can generate. For IRAs owning real estate, generating income can make it an attractive option even without the potential for appreciation. The tax your IRA may incur at the end of an investment is only one factor to consider. Smart investors can generate significant revenue from rent. Cap rates of 4 to 10% are not uncommon and, when compared to returns from other assets, can be very enticing for investors in today’s economy.

In many cases, income generated from real estate assets can cover any Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) required for Traditional IRAs at age 70 ½ .

Remember, the point of owning real estate or any asset in an IRA is to increase the total value of your IRA.

Like all investments, due diligence is required to decide what will work best for your IRA and its investments. New Direction IRA can help with the administration and bookkeeping of your IRA, and will ensure your transactions and/or conversions are done according to IRS code.

Browse our website for more answers to the most common questions and concerns about self-directed IRAs. New Direction IRA is committed to providing you with the best education so you can self-direct your IRA successfully.

Can I live in my Real Estate IRA property?

Question: Is it true I can’t live in or vacation in my IRA-owned real estate?

Benefiting personally from any asset owned by your IRA is prohibited by the IRS. It’s called self-dealing. Furthermore, you can’t let any of your lineal relatives benefit from the asset either; this includes your parents, grandparents, children, grandchildren, spouse and fiduciaries. None of you can live in or lease or vacation in real estate owned by your IRA.

Additionally, you can’t put any personal funds or sweat-equity into the property. New Direction spends the majority of its educational efforts on the rules regarding self-dealing.  Unlike having your IRA own shares of IBM or some other security, the temptation and ability to influence a real estate asset is very real.  Using personal funds or time (“sweat equity”) to benefit the property is strictly prohibited.

Think of it this way: Your IRA is taking advantage of IRS rules that allow it to grow tax-free or tax-deferred. The assets that you purchase with your IRA are not yours, and shouldn’t be viewed as such. We tell our clients that they should think of the IRA as a separate entity (we call it Uncle IRA to illustrate this separation). 

The client’s job is to make good decisions related to the investment, but not have transactions with Uncle IRA or his assets.  These rules are the same for any asset owned by the IRA, but like we mentioned, the temptation to influence real estate owned by your IRA is much greater than other assets. 

When it comes time to distribute the asset, you can certainly take it out of your IRA and live in it then.  It becomes your personal property after distribution. Smart investors will have maximized the investment before then, however, by renting it to tenants or buying property that has increased in value over the years.

Like all investments, due diligence is required to decide what will work best for your IRA and its investments. New Direction IRA can help with the administration and bookkeeping of your IRA, and will ensure your transactions and/or conversions are done according to IRS code.

Browse our website for more answers to the most common questions and concerns we receive. New Direction IRA is committed to providing you with the best education so you can self-direct your IRA successfully.

How to manage a Real Estate IRA

Question: How do I manage expenses and cash flow in an IRA, particularly when I reach retirement age and have to take Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)?

Planning for investment cash flow needs is critical for any investment strategy, particularly illiquid assets like real estate. Annual contribution limits vary from over $50,000 with 401k and SEP-IRA plans down to $3,150 for Health Savings Accounts (all of these plans may be self-directed and are available at New Direction IRA.) The investor needs to determine how much cash will be needed and how much will be available.

When you reach retirement age, you need to take RMDs. This is sometimes tricky for people who only have real estate in their IRA—they’re faced with the prospect of distributing a massive asset, which may incur a lot of tax, to meet the RMD requirements.

Many of our clients choose to own more liquid assets in addition to real estate, such as cash, securities or other alternative assets. Clients also sometimes set up a reserve for unexpected expenses. This allows them to be more flexible, particularly when it comes time to distribute their assets yearly. It is also possible to take incremental “in-kind” distributions of the property itself to satisfy the RMD requirement. This is done by re-titling the real estate each year showing an increasing personal ownership. Although this option may seem complicated it is done.

In addition, real estate is unique in that it can generate cash flow for your IRA. By renting the property to tenants, some clients can generate enough income to offset their RMD requirements.  

Don’t forget that RMDs apply to Traditional IRAs and regardless of what type of asset you hold, it’s only smart to have a plan for how to accommodate these distribution requirements.

If you come across a situation where your IRA cannot afford any incurred expenses, then you should make plans to sell it, bring in other investors, liquidate other assets or make contributions. It is important that you only use IRA funds for all expenses associated with the property including taxes, repairs and insurance. You are not allowed to use personal funds to cover these costs; if you do, your IRA may be disqualified by the IRS.

Like all investments, due diligence is required to decide what will work best for your IRA and its investments. New Direction IRA can help with the administration and bookkeeping of your IRA, and will ensure your transactions and/or conversions are done according to IRS code.

Browse our website for more answers to the most common questions and concerns we receive. NewDirection IRA is committed to providing you with the best education so you can self-direct your IRA successfully.

Depreciation of Real Estate IRA assets

Question: If I purchase property with non-IRA funds, I can write off depreciation but I can’t if I buy it with my IRA.  Why should I give up what appears to be such a significant tax advantage? 

This is probably the most common question we receive. Rather than giving up the depreciation tax advantage, you are trading it for a different and possibly better tax advantage.

Essentially, if you buy real estate with personal funds, you can expense a portion of the cost of the real estate over the allowed time period, usually 27.5 to 39 years.  Depreciation expense, which doesn’t require current cash (since you already invested the cash when you initially purchased the property) lowers your taxable income. 

IRA-purchased real estate is different and carries its own significant tax advantage. Money in a Traditional IRA has already been 100% deducted at the time of contribution, thus there is no basis left for an individual to deduct.  Money made in a Roth IRA, though not deducted when contributed, is tax free for the future. Either case is better than having to depreciate the property over 27 years or more.

The majority of our clients have money that is already in their 401k or IRA either from their personal contributions or their employer’s contributions. They are already enjoying the benefits of the tax-deferred or tax free money. The only way they could use those funds to purchase real estate personally would be to take it out of the plan, giving up its special tax status and in the case of Traditional IRAs, cause a current income tax.

Comparing post tax money in your pocket to pre-tax or tax-deferred money in your retirement plan is not comparing apples to apples. Since the tax advantaged money in the plan is, in effect, not yours until you take it out of the plan, the real goal is to grow the retirement fund as much as possible. How will you grow your IRA?

Some investors will search for property that is likely to appreciate in value. Our clients have invested their IRAs in land that they figured would grow in value in the future, while others bought property to rent out and generate a steady income.

Like all investments, due diligence is required to decide what will work best for your IRA and its investments. New Direction IRA can help with the administration and bookkeeping of your IRA, and will ensure your transactions and/or conversions are done according to IRS code.

Browse our website for more answers to the most common questions and concerns about self-directed IRAs. New Direction IRA is committed to providing you with the best education so you can self-direct your IRA successfully.

Is it expensive to have a Real Estate IRA?

Question: Is it expensive to have a real estate IRA? Won’t I have to pay a ton of custodial fees to manage a real estate IRA?

It’s not expensive to invest your IRA in real estate. At New Direction, we have a structured fee schedule so you’ll know exactly what you have to pay and when. These fees include a one-time startup fee and no fees until you make your first transaction.

Some people say that because brokers and banks generally only allow traditional investments in your IRA like stocks and bonds, that non-traditional investments somehow cost more money. But any account has costs. We encourage you to do your due diligence and check out fee schedules for securities-based IRA providers and compare that with how much money you can make with a smart non-traditional investment in real estate or precious metals. 

If you want to hold real estate with your IRA, you’ll have to find a provider like New Direction that specializes in holding real estate. There will be different costs than those charged by traditional IRA providers, but we’re confident our fees are competitive—and many times they are lower. In short, you don’t need to pay extra for the privilege to invest in non-traditional assets like real estate with your IRA.

Like all investments, due diligence is required to decide what will work best for your IRA and its investments. New Direction IRA can help with the administration and bookkeeping of your IRA, and will ensure your transactions and/or conversions are done according to IRS code.

Browse our website for more answers to the most common questions and concerns we receive. New Direction IRA is committed to providing you with the best education so you can self-direct your IRA successfully.